The Scar
2002 • 663 pages

Ratings98

Average rating4.1

15

Felt somehow a little flatter than [b:Perdido Street Station 68494 Perdido Street Station (New Crobuzon, #1) China Miéville http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1327891688s/68494.jpg 3221410], and I'm not completely sure why. Maybe just that it wasn't about a city, and therefore didn't resonate with me quite as strongly. I also didn't ever feel like I could really relate to Bellis; I disliked her for her coldness and self-absorption at the beginning, and while I warmed up to her a little over the course of the book, I can't really say I ever felt like I understood her.What points Miéville loses for the weirdly ambiguous ending, he easily gains back with his incredible world-building, complex characters, and some seriously creepy monsters. Not to mention that everything about his writing is completely delicious... As with Perdido Street Station, I found myself reading pretty slowly, sometimes rereading passages several times, because they were so dense with meaning and rewarding to linger over.

October 1, 2012