The Night Witches

If you would like to check out more of my reviews please head on over to beforewegoblog.com

Women's roles in war are always played down or seen as insignificant. Even though, often, women played a huge role in major battles or information gathering. During world war II, women took over major industrial roles typical staffed by men. Women built ships, armaments, and trucks. They took over massive equipment operation, and difficult hard labor. For the US, women staffed over 400,000 support staff positions assisting in the war effort of US militaries. They are essential, but often their stories are not told. Enter Garth Ennis of Preacher and The Boys fame. Plus, about twenty other as great series. He is known for his deep storytelling, and no holds barred dialog. Pretty much anything goes when it comes to an Ennis novel. This is an important point to bring up because The Night Witches is based on a real squadron of female fighter pilots during World War II. Ennis had to mix his gritty storytelling and balance it against any accurate details he can glean from actual true-life events. Ennis quotes John Keegan's shocking dismissal of women as fighter pilots or even as fighters in general with “‘Warfare is ... the one human activity from which women, with the most insignificant exceptions, have always and everywhere stood apart ... [women] never, in any military sense, fight men.'“[1] Little is known specifically about The Night Witches, the soviet government has set to downplay its reliance on female personnel. But much can be guessed from the few personal histories that survived.

In response, Ennis has created a character that is a composite of the available information about female fighters at the time in the form of Anna Kharkova[1]. The premise of the story is disjointed, and I found it challenging to follow, but loosely it is about a group of women, named The Night Witches or Ночные ведьмы or in German, die Nachthexen. (The Germans dubbed them their moniker.) They flew nighttime bombing raids and supported Russian defense and offense. Anna flies everywhere and in all sorts of battles. She has love affairs, loses friends, kills people, and as the story progresses, you can tell that little bits of her soul dies. I think that it is the chaotic and disjointed nature of the story that makes it confusing. I liked Anna as a character, I enjoyed her fierce nature, and even though she is tiny, she is big in life and personality. Those who seek to underestimate her, do it only once. But I did not connect with her as a character except the little snippets of dialog that resonated with me.

Graphically, Russ Braun and Tony Aviña's artwork shine. It is gorgeously done with massive air gun battles and vivid war scenes. The artwork is almost reminiscent of World War 2 recruitment and propaganda posters. You feel like you are there in the scenes.

This story is a hard one to judge because, on the one hand, the artwork and war scenes are some of the best I have read. Snippets and vignettes of Anna's trials as a fighter pilot and on into POW camps are poignant and masterfully done. But as a whole, the story is too disjointed for me to care about Anna genuinely. Or understand the gravity of her actions at the end. I recommend it for the artwork and because it is Ennis because even bad Ennis is still a cut above most other storytellers, but I don't think this is his best work.

[1] https://www.npr.org/2019/03/16/698736932/night-witches-sheds-some-light-on-daring-female-flyers

I don't want a ‘'fictionalized'' account. I don't want the POV of a Nazi. I don't want a ludicrous fictional character -whose only thought is SEX SEX SEX!!!! - that has nothing to do with the actual regiment. I don't want a boy's wet dream about these heroic women who sacrificed everything for freedom. I don't want the POV of a misogynist Soviet pig (my apologies to the lovely, cute animals for being compared to the Soviets)

Are editors and publishers even serious? The Russians and the Germans speak as if they are part of a Hollywood Mafia film. I was waiting for someone to come out and actually say ‘'I'll make him an offer he can't refuse''. And if you are going to play it down for shock value and decorate page after page with intestines, at least make them look realistic. Don't ‘'draw'' them like enormous, twisting, pink doodoos.

This...thing is an absolute blasphemy of the extraordinary story of the Night Witches, the 588th Night Bomber Regiment, the women who showed the Germans how this game was played in the Southern Front.

Don't mess with Russian history (or any history, obviously) if you don't have the chops to do it justice.

What's next? Queen Mary's Army Auxiliary Corps presented as bartenders? The Auxiliary Territorial Service depicted as pole dancers?

How does such trash get published?

ARC from Naval Institute Press and NetGalley.