Ratings1,111
Average rating4.3
5 stars — Oh, wow. It's been some time since a book has made me so full of feelings- like I feel like crying and sobbing. Not because this book is sad, not at all, but more because this is such a beautiful novel.
One of the author reviews describes this book as ‘wrapped up in a big gay blanket'. I've never seen a more apt description of a book. The story is about Linus Baker. He's an everyman, with a good office job and getting older by the minute. He's content with his life, or so he says, but for a job assignment he sent to inspect a magical orphanage (think like an Ofsted worker).
I really like characters like Linus. He reminds me of Bilbo Baggins or Arthur Dent. Those characters who are content with their lives, are a tad pompous and set in their ways, but against their wishes are sent on magical journeys. Linus learns a lot. The character development is rife, all of the characters here grow and develop. It's beautiful to watch.
It's very much a book of being ‘different' but learning to cherish differences and who you are. I think it's interesting that the most common criticism with this book is that it's actually too wholesome. It is, but that's why I love it, so much happiness and comedic moments. It tackles discrimination and has a message of embracing difference. It is a simple message at it's core, but turned into a wonderfully cozy story.
Oh gosh, I don't know what is left to say, this is 5/5, on the favourites list for me. There are times that I laughed out loud- Linus character is endearing but also downright funny (reminds me a little of my own dad). The children are wonderful and the development of every character makes my heart warm. The magical creatures are wonderful. The queer relationships was a beautiful touch. All in, love this book so much, literally made me sob and all emotional at the end.
——
(And in terms of the controversy with the Sixties Scoop. It's not a good thing. But I don't think it's enough to purely hate this book- this book is trying to promote good values and it's clear it had a very surface level impact on the story. But despite this, I think there is a more nuanced conversation needed around the topic and its fair to make criticism.)