The Hobbit
10 • 300 pages

Ratings3,220

Average rating4.3

15
uncannymortal
GrantSupporter

Introduction
When I first picked up The Hobbit, I wasn't entirely prepared for its whimsical and lighthearted tone. I've heard that Tolkien's later works, like The Lord of the Rings, are more epic in scope and serious in style, so it was interesting—and occasionally challenging—to settle into the fairy-tale vibe of this story. Still, I quickly found myself drawn in by the cozy world of hobbits and the promise of adventure beyond the Shire.

Pacing
One aspect that stood out to me was the uneven pacing. Certain conflicts, such as the trolls turning to stone, are resolved almost in the blink of an eye. Meanwhile, other parts—like the journey through Mirkwood—feel deliberately slow. Though it sometimes frustrated me, I grew to appreciate that these slower stretches encourage readers to really live in Tolkien's world. They give time to savor each place, even if it might momentarily stall the forward momentum.

World-Building
Middle-earth as described in The Hobbit is rich and detailed—something Tolkien is famous for. Mirkwood, in particular, left a vivid impression on me. The dense forest, lurking spiders, and general sense of foreboding created a tension that made me eager to turn the pages. It felt like a pivotal moment in the story, heightening both the stakes of the journey and my investment in Bilbo's success.

Characters and Arcs
Bilbo Baggins: At first, I adored Bilbo for his love of comfort and good food (who can't relate?). Over time, I was impressed by his growth—he transforms from a reluctant homebody into a clever, resourceful adventurer.
The Dwarves: They provide wonderful comedic relief and contrast to Bilbo's initial meekness. While I didn't pick up on all the nuances of Thorin Oakenshield's arc during this read, I was surprised by how intensely he fixates on the treasure near the end. On a second pass, I'd like to delve deeper into his pride and the way it affects the rest of the group.
Resolution
The final sections of the book—particularly the Battle of the Five Armies—are packed with action, yet I found them a bit overwhelming. So much unfolds so quickly that it's easy to lose track of the players and motives. When Bilbo returns home, I felt a touch of sadness at how the Shire carried on without him; it underlined just how much Bilbo changed through his journey. It's not a triumphant hero's welcome, but it fits the bittersweet nature of the story's conclusion.

Prose and Style
The whimsical narration, sprinkled with gentle humor and occasional asides, definitely sets The Hobbit apart from what I've heard of Tolkien's later works. While it took some getting used to, that playful tone eventually grew on me. It's part of the charm of experiencing this adventure through Bilbo's eyes—a simple hobbit thrown into extraordinary circumstances.

Final Thoughts
Overall, The Hobbit is a delightful read that blends fairy-tale warmth with moments of genuine peril. Although the pacing can be uneven, Tolkien's world-building and knack for immersive detail ensure that slow passages remain engaging. Bilbo's personal growth is truly the heart of the story, and it provides a compelling contrast to the more grandiose, sometimes greedy ambitions of those around him. For anyone new to Tolkien, this is a great place to start—just be prepared for the enchanting (and occasionally meandering) tone that sets it apart from more conventional fantasy epics.

January 4, 2025