Tell Me What Really Happened

I was provided this book free of charge by NetGalley in exchange for an honest review

In my quest to devour all the books on my list this weekend, I eagerly delved into “Tell Me What Really Happened” by Chelsea Sedoti, anticipating a thrilling ride. Yet, despite its promising premise, my excitement was somewhat dampened as I can only bestow three stars upon it.

The narrative centers on Maylee Hayes and her friends embarking on an overnight camping trip to Salvation Creek. What begins as a seemingly innocent excursion quickly spirals into chaos when Maylee mysteriously vanishes from her tent, leaving her companions bewildered and stranded in the wilderness.

The novel's strength lies in its innovative storytelling format, structured entirely through police interviews with the remaining friends. This method effectively builds tension, keeping readers on edge as the plot unfolds. However, the conclusion falls short, feeling underwhelming in comparison to the escalating suspense.

Character differentiation proved to be another stumbling block, with the protagonists blending into a homogeneous mass, making it challenging to discern their individual voices. Additionally, the incessant focus on Bigfoot felt overwrought, detracting from the overall narrative.

Despite these drawbacks, “Tell Me What Really Happened” offers a gripping read, particularly suited for YA enthusiasts seeking a quick and engaging mystery. While it may not reach the heights of other thrillers, it serves as a satisfying palate cleanser between heavier fare.

3.5 rounded down only because there was so much talk about bigfoot it led to the ending being a smidge anti-climatic

all these characters are terrible people, yet i cannot help but sympathize for all of them...

I really wanted to love this book. I really did.

I hated the format of the book. I get that the author wanted to write from all the POVs but it was annoying. I pushed myself to finish the book and while it was well written and the story was really interesting... I felt the format ruined it for me.

I'm sure I am in the minority here so I don't take my word for whether it was good or not.