Ratings39
Average rating4.1
This is the first in the Lord Peter Wimsey series of stories that includes Harriet Vane. Harriet is introduced as she stands in the dock on trial for murder. Lord Peter immediately determines that she is innocent and sets out to prove it - falling in love with her in the process.
Series
14 primary books15 released booksLord Peter Wimsey is a 15-book series with 15 released primary works first released in 198 with contributions by Dorothy L. Sayers, Alistair Beaton, and Дороти Л. Сэйерс.
Series
11 primary books13 released booksLord Peter Wimsey Chronological is a 13-book series with 13 released primary works first released in 1921 with contributions by Dorothy L. Sayers, Alistair Beaton, and Jill Paton Walsh.
Reviews with the most likes.
I originally read this years ago and was just reminded of it recently, prompting a reread. I probably would have given it 4 or 5 stars then, I remember that I loved the Harriet Vane books more than the others in the series.
This time around... kinda boring. Very expositiony, no emotional growth. I did like some of the minor characters like Miss Climpston and Bill Rum, but Peter seemed rather static. I may just have to reread more of the series!
I wonder if I wouldn't have enjoyed this more if I'd read the previous books in the series.
As is, I don't much care for Lord Wimsey. He's both silly and smart in a way that I don't find charming, not nearly as charming as to justify his flippant attitude. And I think that's something I'm supposed to enjoy about this book. That's not a literary criticism. It's really just my personal taste, I think.
Otherwise, this book is fine. I think the structure – beginning with a trial rather than ending – is very interesting. And there are lots of fun, cultural items from the time that I found entertaining.
But the plot is fairly pat and I just couldn't feel much tension in this book.
Not that it matters for the book itself, but the sound on the audiobook version is not very good.