Specials

I felt like nothing happened. It was the second book all over, but Tally is now special instead of pretty.

We had to DNF at 30% - it's so bad. The fact that this story about people who “cut” themselves to feel “icy” (aka clear-minded) got past publishers is shocking. Even for 2006 - this book does not hold up well in culture today and I really doubt this was as good as I thought it was even in middle school.

I stand by my theory that Scott Westerfeld had the idea for a story about hover boards and wrote a crappy plot around it for 4 books just because he had a contact in the industry. This is one of the worst book series I've tried to read.

Relecture 2020 : “Glacial” comme dirait Tally.
La ficelle écologique est un peu grossière, une fable écolo qui peut se révéler intéressante pour des enfants.

why do authors always do the one thing that you don't want them to? sigh

on to Extras....

Très très chouette fin pour cette trilogie. Dynamique, haletante, extrêmement bien rythmée, très dur à lâcher à vrai dire.

Globalement concernant la série c'est une belle surprise. Il m'a fallu du temps pour la démarrer, principalement à cause des titres et couvertures qui laissaient présager un roman bon marché pour très jeunes adolescentes (disons un croisement entre Twilight et Gossip Girl). Cependant, c'est bien la preuve qu'il ne faut pas juger un livre par sa couverture, car l'histoire développée à travers ces trois tomes est extrêmement intéressante. L'univers dystopien est bien construit et repose sur des principes crédibles, les personnages sont intéressants (et on ne verse pas dans les sentiments à l'eau de rose, ce qui est très bien). Bref, une chouette série YA.

This book was no masterpiece but that doesn't mean I didn't really enjoy it. I love young adult dystopian novels like these. Volume 3, like the other two was fast paced and suspenseful, a real page turner! My favorite thing about the “Uglies” series is the transformations the main character goes through in each novel. It's a rare experience for me to read a book where the protagonist is one of the “bad guys”. The whole time you read Pretties and Specials you know Tally is only being controlled by artificial thoughts and emotions. It's pretty creepy how easily you can become one with the enemy in the “Uglies” universe. It has sort of a Invasion of the Body Snatchers or zombie apocalypse feeling.

The ending felt a little sappy and rushed but then endings are rarely satisfying in young adult books. I didn't particularly like the environmental message yet still thought the idea of David and Tally becoming the new “Special Circumstances” was clever. I have no idea what will happen in the extra volume but I hope it's a worthwhile read. I also hope Tally grows to like David but not too quickly because hey, Zane JUST died.

Less satisfying than the 2nd book, but still manages to have a sense of imagination. Overall, the trilogy is not at the level of Hunger Games, but a pretty good and easy read, with enough ideas thrown in to make it a unique teenage dystopian story..

I am...not sure what I thought of Specials. I had a very difficult time rating it. I almost abandoned the book and, thus, the series before I had read even 15 pages. Thankfully, I pushed past that part and realized that this one had an intriguing storyline and redeeming qualities. There were parts that I really liked, most definitely, but there were parts I wasn't crazy about. And the overall effect of the book was that while I was reading it, I was hooked. If I set it down for more than 10 seconds, I pretty much didn't care about picking it up again. I made myself because I knew I would enjoy it once I started, and I did.

First of all, the Cutters. There is no faster way to turn me off of a book, movie, anything, than to mention cutting. That has always been a subject that affects me deeply. The thought quite honestly makes me want to do two things: cry and throw up. Throw up because simply the concept of self-mutilation makes my stomach churn, and cry because it kills me to know that a person is in enough pain that he/she would turn to cutting him/herself as a solution. Therefore, I had a very difficult time with Specials, as the cutting was a big part of the story.

It was good to see Tally overcome that and everything else by herself, without the need of the cure. Of course, we all knew she would because these books have gotten nothing if not predictable. Predictability is another thing that turned me off this book: none of the “twists” came as a shock to me. Not a one. I am usually fairly intuitive about plot twists, a skill honed from hundreds of hours spent reading mysteries and watching CSI in all its varieties. But I am still thrown for a loop on occasion, and, more often, while I'm not necessarily “surprised” by a twist, I didn't find it obvious, either. That's where these books had been, but they lost it in Specials.

I found myself wanting to know more about what happened with the others. We got a basic rundown of what happened with the entire world, what happened with the other Cutters (especially Shay), but there were parts I wish I had actually seen happen. I wanted the details. I felt like they would have been more interesting than the Adventures of Tally.

A few random points:

- Zane. My poor bb. I figured something like this would happen to him, but still. sob

- “Icy” was a great addition to the vocabulary realm and fit the description very well.

- I was a little put off by David's proclamation at the end of the book. I don't care what you say: black eyes and, especially, pointy, triangular, razor-sharp teeth are creepy, yo (not to mention incredibly hazardous for making out). She doesn't just “look like Tally.” I know David is supposed to look past all her imperfections and love her without regard to her appearance and all that, but this was just a little beyond the boundaries of believability for me. And don't get me started on the fact that the nails were apparently only razor-sharp when it was convenient rather than when they would have been annoying/hazardous/disastrous, which would have been a huge chunk of the time. Unless they were retractable or something, which I may have missed, I'll admit.

Now, I don't want my review to come off too negatively. I did enjoy Specials, and it was a good story. However, it did not live up to the last two books. I am not sure what I think of the next one, either. I definitely want to read it, but I hope it doesn't get too preachy about environmentalism. I am all for recycling and the like, but I don't like getting pounded over the head with it. However, I would like to see how the series ends, so I'll read it, regardless. And, of course, die-hard romantic that I am, I want to see Tally and David's story. I did like Tally/Zane better, but I'm definitely not surprised that Tally/David was where it was headed. And I am not opposed to them; they're cute.

Now, onto the last book in this...trilogy? Wish me luck!

It's been a while since I read this one, but I do remember that the ending could have been a lot better. A certain character dies...gasp!...and it just didn't end the way I wanted it to...

SHIT GOT REAL.

I spent a good deal of time being angry at Tally and the author in this book. Her character and personality completely changed, and while I get that some of that was the point... part of the story was that Tally is able to rewire herself. But she never did end up the Tally we'd grown to love from the first two books.

I hated the main characters throughout most of this installment of the trilogy. I get that it was meant to create drama, but I admit I ended up scanning many chapters, just waiting for Tally and Shay's inevetible switch back to their regular personalities.

Overall, it was a decent series. Interesting concept, but sometimes poor execution.

This 3rd in this trilogy moved at a cracking pace!

Loads of twists and turns in this one. Enjoyed it.

Satisfying end to the series!

I don't know, Tally seemed really passive in this one, for all the running around and fighting that happens. I was really uncomfortable with the cutting, and the semi-glamorization of it (thought this isn't something I have a background in). Also, Tally's decision in the end disappointed me, both who she went with and where she went.