Ratings3
Average rating3.7
Crime novelist and former police officer Nigel McCrery provides an account of all the major areas of forensic science from around the world over the past two centuries. The book weaves dramatic narrative and scientific principles together in a way that allows readers to figure out crimes along with the experts. Readers are introduced to such fascinating figures as Dr. Edmond Locard, the “French Sherlock Holmes”; Edward Heinrich, “Wizard of Berkeley,” who is credited with having solved more than 2,000 crimes; and Alphonse Bertillon, the French scientist whose guiding principle, “no two individuals share the same characteristics,” became the core of criminal identification. Landmark crime investigations examined in depth include a notorious murder involving blood evidence and defended by F. Lee Bailey, the seminal 1936 murder that demonstrated the usefulness of the microscope in examining trace evidence, the 1849 murder of a wealthy Boston businessman that demonstrated how difficult it is to successfully dispose of a corpse, and many others.
Reviews with the most likes.
Although not quite as strong as similar books on the topic, Silent Witnesses was a thorough, decently engaging pop history. Because it's an overview of all the forensic techniques, there isn't really enough time for any particular biography or topic to take center stage and while that was a flaw, in that it meant the story lacked an over-arching narrative, it also gave the author a chance to take a broad scope and put all the pieces together. I would have liked the book to have gone into more depth–it gave one chapter each to different forensic topics, such as ballistics, fingerprinting, blood, and DNA, with illustrative case examples, but every chapter left me wanting to know more. Still, if all you know about forensic science is from CSI, Silent Witnesses is not a bad introduction to the history of the topic, if a little overtly focused on British criminal history at times (which, I suppose can be forgiven, as the author is a British forensic scientist.)