Ratings1
Average rating4
What Kansas really tells us about red state America No state has voted Republican more consistently or widely or for longer than Kansas. To understand red state politics, Kansas is the place. It is also the place to understand red state religion. The Kansas Board of Education has repeatedly challenged the teaching of evolution, Kansas voters overwhelmingly passed a constitutional ban on gay marriage, the state is a hotbed of antiabortion protest—and churches have been involved in all of these efforts. Yet in 1867 suffragist Lucy Stone could plausibly proclaim that, in the cause of universal suffrage, "Kansas leads the world!" How did Kansas go from being a progressive state to one of the most conservative? In Red State Religion, Robert Wuthnow tells the story of religiously motivated political activism in Kansas from territorial days to the present. He examines how faith mixed with politics as both ordinary Kansans and leaders such as John Brown, Carrie Nation, William Allen White, and Dwight Eisenhower struggled over the pivotal issues of their times, from slavery and Prohibition to populism and anti-communism. Beyond providing surprising new explanations of why Kansas became a conservative stronghold, the book sheds new light on the role of religion in red states across the Midwest and the United States. Contrary to recent influential accounts, Wuthnow argues that Kansas conservatism is largely pragmatic, not ideological, and that religion in the state has less to do with politics and contentious moral activism than with relationships between neighbors, friends, and fellow churchgoers. This is an important book for anyone who wants to understand the role of religion in American political conservatism.
Reviews with the most likes.
Despite the title, Wuthnow is writing a sociologically-informed history of the interaction between religion and public life in Kansas. It rebuts the Frank’s What’s the Matter with Kansas by showing how religion largely served as a pragmatic, centrist framework knitting local communal life together.
However, in each case - slavery, populism, prohibition, evolution, and abortion - Kansas has served as a stage upon which national movements descended to act out an moral drama, sparking a blaze from plenty of dry local tinder. Geographically and politically, Kansas has served as a sort of American center stage.
Social-political movements in Kansas succeeded only to the extent they adopted a grammar of reaction to national forces hostile to its own religious values.