Perfect State

Audio read by: Christian Rummel

A snipe hunt for the most absurd matrix-like book suddenly gets interesting in the last moments and I'm left wanting more...

7/10

I wanted to like this more than I did. And I expected to like it more than I did. I will say the second half of the book held my interest better than the first.

It definitely feels inspired by the basic idea of The Matrix. the whole brain in a jar/vat bit

Basically, I'm glad that I read it but I doubt I will want to read it again.

Oh, and I'm still looking forward to getting around to reading the epic fantasy novels Sanderson is really known for.

An interesting story, and i liked the ending, but there are a couple of logic inconsistencies that are driving me nuts.

First, if the world is so over populated that humanity has to live as brains in jars, why is reproduction being mandated? Don't reproduce, population issue solved. Second, I see no reason why the subjects have to have what is basically virtual sex in order for that to happen. Get their consent for it to happen, allow them to choose who it's with if they care, and that would seem all that's needed.

I expect better of Sanderson.

As usual Brandon sets a great pace even if the concept is very Matrix in territory. Funny, enjoyable and intriguing it's worth the time invested

At the beginning of this one, I really wasn't into it. I think that was the point. Perfect State takes a look at what would happen if you started with a somewhat boring character and shape them into a hero – but in a non-traditional short story. This could be described (and this isn't spoiling anything, as it's explained early on) as the first version of the Matrix, the one where people got everything they wanted, but where each person is in their own isolated universe. When people who have only talked to AIs decide to talk to other actual humans, things get interesting.

At the beginning of this one, I really wasn't into it. I think that was the point. Perfect State takes a look at what would happen if you started with a somewhat boring character and shape them into a hero – but in a non-traditional short story. This could be described (and this isn't spoiling anything, as it's explained early on) as the first version of the Matrix, the one where people got everything they wanted, but where each person is in their own isolated universe. When people who have only talked to AIs decide to talk to other actual humans, things get interesting.

Perfect State is the story of Kai, the conquerer of the world. Well, at least of his world. Kai is actually living in a simulated world that is perfectly tailored to making him a hero. Which means he is fantastic at everything. Until he is told by the higher powers that he need to procreate, and is forced to go on a date. With the usual Brandon Sanderson flare, hilarity and awesome adventures ensue.

I've read nearly all of Brandon Sanderson's works, so I've become quite used to his style as an author. I have to say that Perfect State stood out from the rest, in a good way. Sanderson gets a bit edgier than in his other works, and it really worked for this story. The world-building and plot, as always, are fantastic. The setup of the story allows for all the cool things, while still making total sense, which makes my geeky little heart do a happy dance. The characters are fun, and definitely have the typical Sanderson snark that I've come to expect from the non-cosmere crowd. I suppose one could criticize how all of his characters have the same tone when they banter, but it's fun banter, so I really don't mind at all.

I really loved the ending of this story. It is the perfect blend of depressing, thought provoking, and hopeful. There are so many little details that I loved about this story, but I don't want to give away too many spoilers, so I won't list them here. I'm just going to say “I loved it” and leave it at that. The story is fairly short and reads very quickly - I read it while traveling and finished it in one sitting between other books during the trip. This is the sort of story I think everyone will enjoy. It's fun, it's quick, it's inexpensive, and it's good. Highly recommended.

Sanderson can't write a short story to save his life, but this was a nice interlude.