Ithaca

I really enjoyed this book. As the first installment of a series, you expect to have a fairly open-ended narrative that could reasonably continue, but I felt Ithaca did a nice job wrapping up the immediate story satisfactorily. The narrator being Hera was an unexpected but nice touch, allowing us to get a truly omnipotent view of the action with some snarky observations thrown in for good measure. Despite (or perhaps because of) her Goddess nature, Hera is an unreliable narrator, prone to favoritism and grudges, and this adds some interesting color to her interactions with the minor cast, especially Athena and Clytemnestra.

Penelope is a smart woman and a capable leader, but as a main character I felt I didn't get a great picture of her. Hopefully she comes into focus more in subsequent books.

The kids love this one. I think my favorite character is... WALTER, the staring fish of horror.

It was fine. I read this with my book club, to be honest I probably would have DNF'd it otherwise. The main problem was that it just did not really capture my attention. The first part meanders a lot and does not have a clear storyline or compelling characters. The second part gets slightly better both the storylines with Clytaimnestra and the one about the raiders picked up a bit, but still there was not enough there to be really invested. I feel like the story would have been more interesting if we had Penelope's POV instead of Hera. It feels like the writer really wanted an all-knowing narrator, but Hera was just complaining about basically everyone else most of the time, which was at times entertaining, but other times too much and trying a bit too hard to be funny. I don't think there were a lot of storylines we could not have had with Penelope being the main character instead of Hera, possibly with some other character POV's sprinkled throughout. And the presence of the gods could instead be shown by characters catching glimpses of them or feeling their presence or something like that.

For me the interesting part of the story was how Penelope was pretending to be a "weak grieving wife" while secretly working behind the scenes with other women to save the island. I would have liked to have seen more of the sceming of Penelope and the women around her. My favorite bit was (not super spoilery):

"Ah," mutters Penelope. "I see. Medon, forgive me. I find myself overcome with womanly weakness and must retire." -"I have always admired the exquisite timing of your weaknesses my lady"

I kept this on as mindless background noise far longer than I paid attention to it, so I give it some credit for that. But I kept zoning out and realizing I hadn't been listening for probably whole chapters, and when I realized I didn't care enough to go back and restart those, it was time to turn it off.

Rating: 5 leaves out of 5
Characters: 5/5
Cover: 5/5
Story: 5/5
Writing: 5/5
Genre: Children
Type: Book
Worth?: Yes

This book's style didn't really work for me, I never felt attached to any of the characters or the stakes involved. However, the prose was thought provoking and lyrical at times, I just wish it engaged with substance more as well as style.

This book is HILARIOUS. You must read this book. Must!

Penelope the T-Rex can't wait to meet her new classmates on the first day of school. But is she ever surprised to find out they are all...children! And they look...delicious....

Hilarious story of trying to fit in while trying to avoid nibbling on our friends, with lots of clever little asides and great illustrations.