Ratings41
Average rating4
In the Penal Colony is a short story by Franz Kafka written in German in October 1914, revised in November 1918, and first published in October 1919. The story is set in an unnamed penal colony. Internal clues and the setting on an island suggest Octave Mirbeau's The Torture Garden as an influence. As in some of Kafka's other writings, the narrator in this story seems detached from, or perhaps numbed by, events that one would normally expect to be registered with horror. "In the Penal Colony" describes the last use of an elaborate torture and execution device that carves the sentence of the condemned prisoner on his skin before letting him die, all in the course of twelve hours. As the plot unfolds, the reader learns more and more about the machine, including its origin and original justification. The story focuses on the Explorer, who is encountering the brutal machine for the first time. Everything about the machine and its purpose is told to him by the Officer. The Soldier and the Condemned (who is unaware that he has been sentenced to die) placidly watch from nearby. The Officer tells of the religious epiphany the executed experience in their last six hours in the machine. Eventually, it becomes clear that the use of the machine and its associated process of justice – the accused is always instantly found guilty, and the law he has broken is inscribed on his body as he slowly dies over a period of 12 hours – has fallen out of favor with the current Commandant. The Officer is nostalgic regarding the torture machine and the values that were initially associated with it. As the last proponent of the machine, he strongly believes in its form of justice and the infallibility of the previous Commandant, who designed and built the device. In fact, the Officer carries its blueprints with him and is the only person who can properly decipher them; no one else is allowed to handle these documents.
Reviews with the most likes.
The first work of Franz Kafka that showed me he wasn't completely pessimistic. The story implies that evil and tyranny are self-destructive but stupid ignorant people can always bring them back and that we have to debar them always from any power to prevent tyrannic rulers from coming to power. I love the story and the ending. Franz Kafka is one of the greatest writers to have ever existed.
Kafka highlights the human desire for judgement and revenge that, for better of for worse, is present throughout human history. In the case of the officer in the story, justice is swift and brutal, seeing guilt as beyond doubt. The perspective of the visitor, however, shows us the fanaticism of the officer and cowardice of the crowds who came to watch the machine in the past yet now object to it's use when they are no consequences on them for doing so. Kafka never attempts to provide a solution to the problems in many justice systems, only showing us the moral failings and condemnations that we ignore. Even the officer, in his dedication to his morals and justifications for his actions, submits himself to the machine in the end as he sees the shift in perspective around him and is ultimately killed by his refusal to reconsider his actions. It clearly represents to us the excuses and justifications that have been used all throughout history to justify actions that would normally seem reprehensible to those who commit them.
While this is not my favourite of Kafka's works, I think it teaches many important lessons and has nuances I am not smart enough to fully understand, but even on the surface the level the messages it includes about our attitudes to justice and morals, and how we justify our actions are clear and important.
Realmente aterrorizante. Por muitos momentos a mente por trás daquele “aparelho” cruel me espantou. Uma boa novela e uma escrita magnifica do Kafka.