If We Were Villains

If We Were Villains opens with the main protagonist, Oliver Marks, just about to leave prison after serving a 10 year sentence for murder. The detective who put him there is about to retire, and asks him for answers - did he really do it? What actually happened 10 years ago?

The novel follows a group of theater students at an elite arts college. It is darkly atmospheric, and they don't seem to just act out Shakespeare, they live it, completely immersing themselves at times. Like any tightly woven group of friends, the relationships are complex; family, friends, lovers, enemies. Loyalty, obsession, consequences. These people seem to love each other and ruin each other all at the same time. And of course, you can't have Shakespeare without tragedy, can you? This book is half mystery and half literary homage.

Did I like it? I suspect that if I had been a theatre kid, I would have. It was masterfully written, and I was interested enough in the story to stick to the end to find out ‘who dun it' and see if my suspicions were correct. Although, I will ‘WHAT?!' to that ending? I need at least one more chapter! That WAS an entirely unexpected reveal.

But in the end, it's probably not one I'll keep on my bookshelf. As always though, that's because the atmosphere and setting just weren't to my particular tastes. On a technical and artistic level, I believe this is a very good book, and I suspect it will have a very appreciative audience.