Habibi
Ratings84
Average rating4.3
Got introduced to Craig Thompson's genius through Blankets. Although the story is good, I felt religion had too much of an impact on the storyline. As always, stunning artwork, making it a joy to read. But I still prefer Blankets over Habibi.
I wrote quite a lengthy review which delved into the many reasons I didn't feel Habibi was designed to be offensive. I illustrated the sensitivity Thompson showed the subject and the fantastic nature of the story. I talked about authorial intent and explored each of the complaints raised against Habibi, one by one. Then I decided to scrap it and start all over again.
I do believe Thompson empathized greatly with his Arabic and female characters. I believe his intentions were largely pure and made of love. I think he was striving to write a fairy tale about the depravity of humanity; setting it in an Arabic landscape may have given the impression that Thompson was dehumanizing Arabs, but I believe he would've given the same treatment to any people regardless of the setting. I also think that the abuse he subjected Dodola to throughout this novel was not meant to glorify rape and sexual trauma. As a reader, I felt Dodola's anguish and thought her very strong and wise. Of all the characters, she was the most humanized. Yet, others read her as a weak portrayal of women, a submissive character designed to embolden male lusts.
Rather than go into all my arguments again, I've decided it doesn't matter what I believe. The fact is, this novel, wonderful and nearly perfect in so many ways, also carries with it much hurt. One may see the hurt and say, “My heart bleeds for these characters. I want to help women who suffer from this kind of abuse.” Others will justify their own feelings of hatred and say, “Finally, an accurate depiction of those nasty Muslims.” And some may respond with hurt and say, “How dare he! Thompson is a misogynist and a racist!” None of these responses can be controlled and authorial intent doesn't matter when you're the one whose emotions have been stirred.
Habibi is an emotionally engaging book, as is indicated by the huge number of both five star and one star reviews this novel has garnered since it was published in 2011. Thompson's depictions of both the Middle East and of women can be troubling, depending on which lens you're viewing them with. Personally, I saw the hurt subjected by a depraved species; I did not see an object of hatred, but rather a letter written in love. Perhaps Thompson got some things wrong. Perhaps he would've done better to have stayed out of the Middle East. I'd be happy to share my more detailed thoughts with any who might be interested, but rather than add fuel to the argument and possibly cause more pain, I'll leave those thoughts out of my review proper.
Though I only began reading graphic novels a little over a year ago, I recognize the artistry and innovation of Habibi. It is the most well constructed and intelligent graphic novel I've read. It is lush with imagery that one could spend years dissecting. It blends worlds, periods, and ideologies, and does so without the reader even noticing. Yet, there could've been more. For such a lengthy book, I didn't feel I really got to understand Dodola or Zam. Giving us more about who they were might have made it easier to view them as more than simple victims and increased the empathy readers had for them.
Habibi is an epic story that bleed in black ink all over these 670 pages. It can be viewed as a gorgeous outpouring of emotion, or an embittered tirade against justice. One cannot deny, for better or worse, Craig Thompson has ushered in a new era in graphic novels.
Reading Habibi is like watching Craig Thompson juggle with chainsaws. The huge ideas he works with: the intractable divisions of gender, sex, ecology, religion, and colorism, are live and dangerous and complicated. He chose to set this story in a dreamlike world outside of time and concrete geography, and it frees him to explore these divisions as aspects of the human condition.
There are no easy answers found in this story, grey area is everywhere and anyone looking for relief or prescriptions is bound to be disappointed. Except maybe in the values of story and art. Story, art, words and ink are intwined, and I have to note as well that I cannot think of a more beautiful object than the book that is and contains this story.
The only thing I could think of while reading this was how much Thompson has grown since his work on Blankets. His art is ten times better and the story a hundred times as ambitious. A lot of themes are covered including the connection of Christianity and Islam and the difference between love and lust. This book is really great, and absolutely gorgeous. With that being said, Thompson set some tremendous goals for himself, and I'm not sure he hit every mark. Even when it's fiction, it's hard for me to accept things being told about religious people of color in the Middle East when it is coming from the mouth of a young, white, agnostic American. I know it's not entirely fair of me to dismiss an entire book because of the author's nationality, but the book is sometimes unclear on what is being glorified, what is being condemned, and what is being included for the sake of being sensational. This was written immediately after closing the book, so my thoughts are not fully formed. I'm having my doubts but overall the impression on me was very positive.
This was amzing. I've been looking forward to this book for a long time. I really enjoyed the art and the importance of stories, the comparative religion was one of my favorite themes.
There are a few things however that interrupted my enjoyment of the book. In the beginning of the book it was a little difficult to follow the order of events and the jumping in the story, but it was manageable. What was bigger than that was the settling was jumbled – for the majority of the book appears to take place hundreds of years ago, but then later in the book they appear to be in modern times which is just confusing, and thus (for me) frustrating.
Also did I miss something about her biological son, how does an empty crib automatically mean death? I mean you never gave up on Habibi, but are so quick to just give up on the child that you had recently had a change of heart about?
Heavy topics, race, sex, rape, gender... All of which he may not have gotten correct, but it does give one something to think about.
I'm not quite sure what to think about this. The art is pretty, and the story has fascinating parts; there are some interesting views to Arabic culture, Qur'an and calligraphy.
Then there's tons of female nudity just for the sake it, quite a bit of sex, most of it rape in some form, slavery and rather unpleasant Orientalism.
Wow. Just... wow. This graphic novel kind of blew my mind. It's crazy - crazy rich, crazy complex, and crazy visionary. Craig Thompson is also crazy talented. And also maybe just crazy. It blasted me with so much information and impressive curlicues of style and form, that I don't think I can even really judge it in any objective way. It was just kinda overwhelming, ya know!
Um, okay... gathering my thoughts. So... um. It's set in an (unreal?) Islamic realm by a modern-looking city of Wanatolia. There's a very classical-looking and classical-behaving sultan, complete with 1,001 nights ultimatums (entertain me, or you die!), a huge harem, eunuchs, slaves, fountains, dates, and so forth. There's a village, which looks like a serious blast from the classical Arab past. There are caravans in the desert. There's a huge modern dam. Okay, it's confusing. The context is very difficult to pin down. 75% into the book, I went “ah HA! This is 19th century Istanbul!” Now I'm not so sure.
What is understandable is the central story (told, as it is, in a circuitous, rambling way with many rotations through time) of Dodola, a beautiful Persian (?) woman who is basically objectified, abused and prostituted constantly, and a young dark-skinned boy she rescues from the slave market, Zam. Dodola and Zam briefly live on a ship in the desert. Then they are split up - Dodola becoming the sultan's favorite courtesan, and Zam growing up, tortured by his sexuality and trying not to starve.
What is this book trying to say?! The narrative is constantly embellished with incredibly rich asides regarding stories from the Qur'an, Arabic calligraphy, geometry and science. At times, you think Dodola is supposed to be the archangel Gabriel. Then you think she's the Prophet. Then you think she's Noah. Then you think Zam's Noah. Then there's a long, touching substory about hijras - but wait! We're clearly not in the subcontinent (or are we? some characters sometimes wear salwar kameezes or saris). Is this an elaborate pun on hijra/Hijra?!
Anyway, ultimately, Habibi is an extensive, mystical Sufi meditation: love God/Allah, but love love first. Islam (and religion) is treated with wide-eyed reverence - though I don't think Thompson is Muslim? But the ultimate message is - I think - about how we tell stories to ourselves to make sense of the world, but ultimately we don't need those stories. And we should throw them away if they hurt us. And the guiding principle of everything is this one. And, okay, I cried.
Excellent graphic novel - It was a Christmas gift and I spent that night reading it. I couldn't stop reading because I want to know what was going to happen to Dodola and Zam. Thompson spent 6 years working on this graphic novel and it shows . . .
One of the great monuments of storytelling is The 1,001 Nights, or The 1,001 Arabian Nights, as it has come to be known in the West. It is a collection of stories from various Middle Eastern, South Asian, and North African cultures, gathered together over century upon century into the collection familiar to readers today. The first English translation of the stories first appeared in 1706, when it was known by the title The Arabian Nights' Entertainment.
The collection of stories contained within varies, depending on region and translator, but the frame story is almost always the same: a Persian king, traumatized by his wife's adultery, decides that all women must be like her, and weds a succession of virgins whom he executes the following morning, believing that doing so will prevent them from ever dishonoring him ever again. But when the realm runs out of virgins, the vizier's daughter, Scheherazade, volunteers herself as the next bride, and on the night of their marriage, she begins to tell the king a story, but ends it on a cliffhanger at dawn so that the king is forced to stall her execution until she finishes the story. She does so, but continues with another story, and on and on, for a few hundred nights or the literal one thousand and one, depending on the version one reads. Whatever the case, Scheherazade is spared the executioner's block, and she and the king live happily ever after.
The tales themselves are richly varied in their content: tragedies, comedies, romances, historical tales, poetry, even erotica. Sometimes these stories themselves form the frames for even more stories, so that, like Russian matryoshka dolls or Chinese nested boxes, the stories are layered, one within the other, forming a rich tapestry of narratives one could easily compare to the intricate latticework so common in Arabic decorative motifs.
Craig Thompson's latest work, Habibi, is easily compared to The 1,001 Nights, albeit the comparison is rather loose. True, there is a beautiful storyteller, and there is a king somewhere along the way, and the settings are strange and exotic, but this is absolutely not The 1,001 Nights. Habibi is about other things, things that are as timeless as The 1,001 Nights, but which are still valuable - and maybe more valuable - to contemporary readers.
On the most obvious level, Habibi is a story about two people: Dodola and Zam. Their first meeting in a slave market, with Zam still a very young child and Dodola just marked as a slave after her husband's murder, is not only fortuitous, but also fated. For several years after that first meeting and their subsequent escape from the slave market, they live together out in the desert, in a boat that has somehow been left behind in the middle of all that sand. But then things go terribly wrong when Dodola is captured by the sultan's men and brought to his harem, where she remains for several more years before a chance encounter with Zam - now a eunuch - brings the two of them back together again, never to be parted.
The novel is, of course, more than just that. With a page count in the upper 600s, there is more to Habibi than a simple love story, and yet love is one of, if not the most, important themes. The title itself, Habibi, is Arabic for “my beloved.” But the love story is not so simple as the summary above might make it. It is far more complex than that, and is not only about romantic love. Like the layered stories in The 1,001 Arabian Nights, love as described and tackled in Habibi is layered and multifaceted, as complex as Arabian latticework. The love shared between Dodola and Zam is just one facet, one aspect: there is so much more said about love in the novel, so much that when the reader reaches that final page, one ends the story with a weight in one's heart and a tear in one's eye for all the love that has been found, lost, and found again.
Habibi also speaks of religion, and more importantly, of faith. The wars in the Middle East in the early 2000s, and the rise of the Arab Spring movement, make Habibi an incredibly timely book when one thinks of how prominent Islam has become in the world's consciousness. Some might be leery of reading Habibi, thinking it a Westerner's take on Islam and thus flawed. Perhaps this might be true, but as far as I can tell, Thompson does not write of anything that might be construed as insulting to any religion. He quotes from the Qur'an, and the hadiths, and the great poets of Islam, but he leaves it up to the reader to come to his or her own decision regarding the material. This is why I say this book is about faith and not religion, per se. That is not the point. Whatever one's religion might be, faith is by far more important. One can call God anything one wants, but this matters little in the long run, or in the end. Faith is what counts, and Habibi emphasizes this - a powerful reminder that, in the 21st century, what one calls one's God really shouldn't be as important as it was in the 10th to 11th centuries.
Another powerful and timely theme explored in the novel is that of humanity's relationship to nature. Over and over again ,the world that Dodola and Zam inhabit is described as “dead” or “dying.” There is a water crisis going on, one that leaves the rich even richer and the poor even poorer, and those who cannot get clean water die from waterborne diseases, or starvation, or dehydration, or all or some combination of the above. Humanity has struggled to control nature, and while this has some immediate, short-term benefits, it has done far, far more harm than good. Again, this will resonate powerfully with readers who are aware of the possibility of such a crisis occurring in the world, or those who may have first-hand experience of such a crisis. One thing is clear in Habibi: if the earth dies, then it is most certainly humanity's fault for allowing greed to triumph.
And then there are the stories Dodola tells. A majority of them appear to be drawn from the Qur'an, and oftentimes Dodola includes a comparable Bible narrative, just to show how similar the primary books of Christianity and Islam are in reality. Given the source of these stories, any experience reading the Qur'an will help in appreciating both Dodola's stories and the main story itself, but it is not absolutely necessary. But this comparison between the Qur'an and the Bible is important in highlighting that the differences between Islam and Christianity - and indeed, in the races that subscribe to one or the other, or even to other faiths entirely - is so minor as to be unimportant. As Dodola realizes in a crucial moment towards the end ofthe novel: “There are no separations.”
All of what has been mentioned so far is well and good, but what makes Habibi unique from all the other novels and books that tackle the same themes, whether separately or together, is Thompson's art. Using Islamic art and calligraphy as the basis for the art of Habibi, Thompson tells a story, already beautiful on its own, using some of the most beautiful and intricate artwork to have appeared outside of the most elaborately-decorated Qur'ans and mosques. While some might like to argue that coloring the entire thing would heighten the beauty of the artwork, I believe that the stark black-and-white brushstrokes that are Thompson's trademark are beautiful enough precisely because they are so sharp and crisp. Part of the beauty of Islamic artwork is that it is based on the precise, mathematical lines of geometry, but softened by the elaborate arabesques and labyrinthine curlicues evolved through the Islamic artists' love of natural forms. This creates an intricate, layered imagery that draws the reader in, creating a fairytale-like sense of the story being told. This style, when applied to the main storyline, Dodola's stories, and then built up by the inclusion of Arabic calligraphy (not all of which is Thompson's; this is clarified in the endnotes), creates the feeling of having stepped into a dream, as it were: an exotic, beautiful dream, but also savage and uncomfortable for the truths it reveals to the reader.
Habibi is simple, and yet complex. It is a love story, and yet so, so much more than just that. It explores many things, both simple and complex, but more often than not, what seems simple is far more complicated and multilayered than what might appear on the surface, and what appears complex is really quite simple, when one gets down to it. Just like the Arabic latticework designs that constantly appear throughout the novel, and just like the examples of calligraphy scattered all throughout, Habibi is a beautiful and heartbreaking exploration of how the simplest things are always the most important, and provide the foundations of everything that is great and enormous in the world.