Ratings25
Average rating3.1
Police Constable Hamish Macbeth is called in to investigate the death of the unpopular Lady Jane, a malicious gossip and student at the Lochdubh School of Casting, Salmon and Trout Fishing, set in the Scottish Highlands
Featured Series
36 primary books38 released booksHamish Macbeth is a 38-book series with 36 released primary works first released in 1985 with contributions by M.C. Beaton, M. C. Beaton, and R.W. Green.
Reviews with the most likes.
I was engaged throughout because I was reading it in German, enjoying the challenge of the language but not particularly impressed with the plot. There was a whole lot of set up, and ultimately the book did not deliver.
I am told that this series gets really good, though this first novel did not contain any evidence of future greatness.
Writing style: Flat and dispassionate.
Characters: Annoying and two dimensional.
Plot: Gratingly predictable.
That said, I've read enough series in which later books are utter classics, but the early books are a slog. I will probably come back and give book 2 a try - but I feel I really need to read something different first for the sake of my teeth - I was grinding them through most of this book.
A fine mystery. With the language and other things, I'm not sure I'd classify it strictly as a cozy, though.