Beauty

A nearly perfect Beauty and The Beast retelling to me! The story is whimsical but still very grounded in reality. The world building pulled me right in as well. I enjoyed many of the characters, especially Beast who was never mean nor cruel to Beauty.

It was almost 5 stars but then Beast had to go turn into a human again

For more of my reviews, check out my blog.

After reading Echo North and being reminded just how much I love the Beauty and the Beast fairy tale, I decided to venture into the world looking for more retellings of this classic story. I discovered that not only have I already read quite a few of them, that there are tons and tons out there for me to grab hold of. Beauty was one of the highly recommended ones, so it shot straight to the top of the list.

In this particular version of the story, Beauty is given the nickname as a joke — she is not the most beautiful of her sisters, and is in fact rather plain. She's more likely to be found in the blacksmith shop helping shoe horses than to be embroidering or painting or whatever it is that noble ladies do with their spare time. I quite liked this version of Beauty — she was down to earth in a way that a lot of other ‘Beauties' usually aren't. When her father returned with his “bargain” with the Beast, Beauty didn't really hesitate to say that she would go. She was expendable in a way that her sisters were not, and well, it wasn't like she had a lot of other prospects in the small little town they lived in.

I love, love, loved the side characters in this one. Beauty's sisters loved and adored her for who she was without really wanting to change her. Their father wanted what was best for them, but after he lost his business he was not too proud to accept help. Beauty's brother-in-law, Gervain, was a champion of men and just one of the nicest characters I've read in awhile. Just lovely people all around in this book. And this is all without mentioning the Beast himself.

The Beast is a lonely man who, if I'm recalling this right (it's been several days since I finished this book), had an ancestor that was cursed. I don't remember if it was Beast himself or another member of his family who was the first person to be cursed and sentenced to live in the magical house until a girl loved and agreed to marry him. He has been in the house for at least two hundred years by the time that we know him. He is very clearly alone, hates it, and wants company. He seemed soft, and extremely kind to Beauty right from the start. After ‘kidnapping' Beauty, the Beast sends countless treasures to her family so they are taken care of, and know that she is safe.

Both Beauty and Beast are outcasts inside the story, and together they fit in a way that neither one of them ever expected to. I loved watching them circle around each other, and then finally fall for one another. It is slowly done, and masterfully done. My one problem with this retelling is the ending. Not only is it extremely abrupt, it leaves you feeling as if you're missing something. I wanted a more rounded ending — maybe some more after they are married, or something similar. Instead, we don't even get to see them wed. It ends right before the wedding, as the guests arrive. I was disappointed, but since I liked the rest of the novel, I'm still rating this one 4 stars.

The ending was so rushed which sucks since the rest of the book is very enjoyable.

I did enjoy this story, but it felt rushed at the ending, and top-heavy, like once Beauty got to the castle, the author no longer knew what to do with the story. And the ending felt unfinished. Yes, happy fairytale ending, but just not complete somehow.

I did love the mention of the library with every book that will ever be written. I'd love to have one of those. And I thought the characters were all quite well drawn. Each of them felt real.

McKinley can paint a picture with words when she wants to. But somehow, I get the impression that she hadn't quite figured out the entire flow of her story. Not a bad read, but not particularly a keeper. Definitely not what I was hoping for.

Beautiful charming Beauty and the Beast retold with a little twist.

Leuk boek, vlot geschreven, maar ergens verwachte ik dat er toch iets nieuws aan het verhaal ging worden toegevoegd.
recensie

I can't really review the book since I didn't finish it. I couldn't get through it - it didn't keep my attention.

OK so I frequently induce seizures in YA book people by telling them that I've never read a Robin McKinley novel. Welllll, I read one! It was pretty good. I had the sensation that I had read this before? But I think maybe that's just because I have read, uh, Beauty and the Beast before. I got pretty caught up in this even though I already knew the story. Whatever, apparently everyone else in the world has already read this book so I'm done reviewing it.