A Dance with Dragons
Ratings1,059
Average rating4.2
This installment was far superior to the previous, though I'm not certain how I feel about where things ended with most of the characters. I do really enjoy the ever more intricate web Martin is weaving–the plots within plots, twists, crazy secrets revealed. However, I would've like a little more payoff in this book, to see at least one really awesome thing happen to at least one of my favorite heroes instead of more betrayals. I am intrigued to see where Martin takes this series next, and fervently hope I will not have to wait 6 years to find out (though I know this is a slim hope).
**Edited to Add**
Now that I've had more time to think on this, I've actually downgraded my rating by one star, because for all the pages, not a whole lot actually happens to move the plot forward. When will everyone finally get to where they're going? The whole book was spent on ships and in marches. I get it, GRRM, war takes time, politics is messy, yadda yadda. Now can you move your characters forward, please? And for the love of all that is holy, can the Stark children PLEASE know that the others aren't dead so they can stop making assinine decisions based on this mistruth?
Definitely a set-up book to prepare for what hopefully will be a fucking epic 6th book, which hopefully will not take another 6 years to be published... Otherwise, I was a little disappointed. And soooo messed up about the Theon/Reek chapters. Those made me nauseous and teary even though I hated Theon forever.
As much as absolutely loved the first three books of Martin's A Song of Ice And Fire series, this one along with A Feast For Crows felt like a lot of filler. Originally, by Martin's own admission, he planned to have a gap of years after the third book and then to jump back in, but in tracing out the events that would occur during the gap so that he knew where all the characters would be at the start of his new story cycle, he got excited about the stories and decided to write them rather than have them skipped. The beginning of the series, A Game of Thrones, doesn't begin at the beginning. Much has happened in the land of Westeros, and part of the brilliance of the first three books is how they weave in details of the wars and events that came before without bogging down the story. You get the information you need, you understand that those tales you aren't being told are exciting and important, but you are in this story here which is also exciting. AFFC and ADWD contain elements of that, flashing back to days before AGOT, and those turn out to be the best parts of the books. The rest of it feels like moving chess pieces around a board with the occasional taking of a pawn and little else.
Despite the lackluster experience with these two books, I'll continue reading the series, but I can't help but feel that Martin should have stuck to his original plan, skipped some time and picked up the story again when all the players we in place again.
Loved it as expected, took an age to get through, also as expected and what an ending! You can't do that! Although to be fair he has been getting rid of characters at a good rate.
I would liked to have seen more of Bran, especially once they got to where they were going. Some Rickon would have been good, and a bit more Arya at the end there, she's got to come back to Westeros surely?
My only critique of this book is that I feel like it stops right when it's getting very good. A common critique for a good book in a series I suppose. But I felt much of Dany's storyline felt like prelude and only got meaty in her last chapter. Jon Snow's bits were more satisfying, but my what a cliffhanger! And Tyrion while extremely entertaining seems to float upon the top of the plot without yet getting to his purpose. I could have done with a few more chatters on Ty and Dany, but then again I wouldn't have wanted to wait a few more years to get them!
Fans have been looking forward to this one for a LONG time. A Dance with Dragons completes the story begun six years ago, when A Feast for Crows was published in October, 2005. In Feast, fans were given the full story, but only for half the characters. Fan favorites like Tyrion Lannister, Jon Snow and Daenarys Targaryen were noticeably missing from the chapters of the book. Martin's now-infamous claim that Dance would be finished within a year ended up haunting him relentlessly until the day that A Dance with Dragons fell into everyone's eager hands. A Dance with Dragons not only completes the story of that missing half, but also continues the story forward. In fact, Dance is the largest book in the series, weighing in at 1,040 pages.
So how does this fifth entry in the Song of Ice and Fire series match up to the rest? Read on to find out.
Note: It's presumed you've read the series up to the ending of A Feast for Crows, so if you haven't, don't read on.
The Prologue certainly draws comparisons to that in A Game of Thrones, taking place far north of the Wall, and giving us glimpses of the White Walkers. This serves to continue the inexorable march of the undead towards the rest of Westeros. Martin is most certainly taking his time drawing out the inevitable confrontation with the Others, however, and some readers may wonder if he'll ever be able to complete this saga, much less in the two books he claims remain. Nevertheless, it's a promising start to the novel.
Tyrion Lannister
Finally, after ten long years, fans get new Tyrion material. His story begins perfectly in Dance and we see the Imp wallowing in self-pity and taking careless chances, his life no longer important to him. It doesn't take long for that attitude to change, with the help of some unlikely allies, and rather unexpected revelations.
Tyrion sees his ups and downs in this novel, and his luck continues to hold, especially near the end. He's matched up with another dwarf, but where this pairing is going is hard to say. Tyrion's line that he has a heart for “cripples, bastards and broken things,” is never so apt as in this novel. His story does wander a bit, and he's not as endearing as in his previous forays, but he's still very much Tyrion Lannister, and he entertains us nonetheless.
Daenarys Targaryen
Unfortunately, Daenarys Targaryen's return after a decade-long hiatus does not go as well as the dwarf's. She is certainly a willful young woman, but she borders on annoying and insolent throughout the novel. She seems to disregard every piece of advice her advisers give her, always questioning herself, but then stubbornly refusing to reconsider. Though she's the mother of dragons, we unfortunately see very little of them until the latter parts of the book, which is frustrating, considering how integral they seem they must be to the series.
There are some truly exciting portions of the novel in this book, however; One scene in particular seems to be what fans have been waiting for since the moment the dragons were brought to life in the burning embers of Khal Drogo's funeral pyre. It should bring a chill to readers' spines, and was perfectly written–leaving the reader wondering about the fate of the character, of course.
Jon Snow
Jon arguably has the best plot line in the novel, both fleshing out his character further, as well as one of the most surprising final chapters of the book. Strange how the Starks all seem to have the best stories.
There's also an early scene where Jon dispenses justice Eddard-style. It's an unexpectedly welcome scene, not only makes for good reading, but also draws the reader back into the story, which until then founders a little bit.
Davos Seaworth
In A Feast for Crows we learn that Davos is dead. Since Dance takes place during the same timeframe, we get to see his actual situation play out. Without spoiling things, let's just say that Davos' parts are rather boring, most of the time, though Martin leaves things sufficiently appropriate for Davos Seaworth.
Theon Greyjoy
It's been 13 years since we last got into the head of Theon Greyjoy, all the way back in the second book of the series, A Clash of Kings, published in 1998. Martin seemingly killed off the young kraken, but readers have heard bits and pieces about him throughout the series. In A Dance with Dragons, fans finally learn the fate of Theon. Theon's storyline is one of the most interesting of the book, second only to that of Jon Snow.
Bran Stark
Bran has a very interesting story in the novel, but one that seems to end much too quickly. His almost feels like a dropped story thread, and fans will wonder what's happening with him later in the book without ever finding out. This is presumably one of the characters who will see more time in the next entry in the saga.
Quentin Martell
Quentin Martell is the son of the Prince of Dorne, and fans are given quite a bit of time with this character. Ultimately, his part doesn't feel that important to the story, and one is left wondering why he is even a part of it. The importance of Dorne's storyline is becoming more apparent throughout Dance, but it still feels like it's late to the party.
Arya Stark
Still very much in Braavos, Arya was left blind in her last outing. Hers is one of the most involved stories in all of the Ice and Fire saga, and it continues to be no less enveloping in this latest entry. It's still unclear exactly where her thread is leading her, but fans shouldn't be disappointed by her brief appearances in Dance.
Victarion Greyjoy
It's not very clear how Victarion will ultimately play into the saga, but his parts are not at all dull.
Jamie Lannister
When the book finally catches up to the end of A Feast for Crows readers are reunited with Jamie, and his quest to unite the riverlands. He only appears in one chapter in Dance, but it's a fantastic one, with a very suitable cliffhanger ending.
Cersei Lannister
Fans will be very pleased with Cersei's chapters in A Dance with Dragons. The queen has already been brought low, and will sink even further before things are through. Fans may even begin to feel sympathy for her in this round, though they'd be hard-pressed to ever forgive her. Cersei has been the character that fans love to hate, so Dance is all the more shocking for making her seem more human.
Brienne of Tarth
Another character that only appears once, and not as a viewpoint character. Fans won't get a lot of information about what's been happening with her, or what her ultimate fate is, but her presence is crucial to the chapter, feels unexpected, and is perfect.
The Red Priestess Melisandre
Readers are welcomed into the mind of Melisandre for the first time in A Dance with Dragons and given a look at what her plans might be. It's revealed that she's not infallible, and can doubt herself after all. There are some reasonably surprising events revolving around Melisandre in this novel as well.
Stannis Baratheon
Readers have still not seen events from the viewpoint of the truly legitimate King, and after A Dance with Dragons, it's uncertain if it will ever happen. Indeed, Stannis has a lot to do in this book, with very little to show for it. He appears a few times early in the book, then mostly those that surround him allude to him for the remainder. It's fitting that readers should spend more time with his subjects than with the King himself, however.
Ser Barristan Selmy
Selmy is still with Daenarys and serves as the sole member of her Queensguard. Throughout the saga, he's been a bit of a secondary character, but with A Dance with Dragons, he leapfrogs right into major character status. His parts are interesting, treacherous, and fitting for the aged knight. Fans will have much more respect for Ser Barristan before the Dance is through.
Varys the Eunuch
Appears only once, and very briefly, but is the most shocking and enjoyable chapter in the book.
Missing Characters
Ultimately, there are a few characters that do not appear in the novel, their fate uncertain.
- Catelyn Stark
- Rickon Stark
- Sansa Stark
- Samwell Tarly
- Peter Baelish (Littlefinger)
Summary
A Dance with Dragons does indeed feel much like A Feast for Crows did, though is certainly a better novel; it feels dark and gritty. Winter is most certainly coming, as evidenced by Martin's use of the weather throughout the book. Once it snows in King's Landing, it's quite clear how winter is going to affect events in the series.
Once Dance catches up to the ending of Feast, things move along a little faster, but this book still doesn't live up to the greatness of A Clash of Kings and the chaos that was A Storm of Swords. There are moments that drag along, and there are characters included that feel unnecessary or confusing. Fortunately, Martin moves the story along nicely in this book, and it truly feels like there's an end-game coming, though it's still unclear what exactly that is.
The author has stated that there are at least two more books left in the saga, currently titled The Winds of Winter and A Dream of Spring. Though those titles are intriguing, A Dream of Spring doesn't sound like the title of a book that would wrap up this amazing series. It seems like in a song of Ice and Fire, things should end in a blazing inferno, and fire should be a part of the title. Mayhaps there will be another entry in the series. Time will tell, of course, but with the delay between these books growing longer, let's hope not too much time is necessary.
Rating: 4.0 of 5
- Reviewed by Bradley K. Brown
Good book. Really can't wait for more.
I do wonder, however, how GRRM is going to finish his epic off. At the end of ADWD he has multiple threads hanging. Oh the suspended suspense ...
Fair warning: If you are new to the “A Song of Ice and Fire” series, don't start here. You will just get confused. Start with the first book – “A Game of Thrones”.
Maybe not as good as [b:A Game of Thrones 13496 A Game of Thrones (A Song of Ice and Fire, #1) George R.R. Martin http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1239039164s/13496.jpg 1466917], but definitely deserves to be considered as the best of the Song of Ice and Fire. It has the quick-moving plot of [b:A Game of Thrones 13496 A Game of Thrones (A Song of Ice and Fire, #1) George R.R. Martin http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1239039164s/13496.jpg 1466917], the intricate political intrigue of [b:A Clash of Kings 10572 A Clash of Kings (A Song of Ice and Fire, #2) George R.R. Martin http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1307734601s/10572.jpg 3272005], and even a little bit of the madness of [b:A Storm of Swords 62291 A Storm of Swords (A Song of Ice and Fire, #3) George R.R. Martin http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1298429990s/62291.jpg 1164465]. And, best of all, it has none of the flaws of [b:A Feast for Crows 13497 A Feast for Crows (A Song of Ice and Fire, #4) George R.R. Martin http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1288333578s/13497.jpg 1019062]. Even the ironmen are interesting in this one.
Maybe not as good as [b:A Game of Thrones 13496 A Game of Thrones (A Song of Ice and Fire, #1) George R.R. Martin http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1239039164s/13496.jpg 1466917], but definitely deserves to be considered as the best of the Song of Ice and Fire. It has the quick-moving plot of [b:A Game of Thrones 13496 A Game of Thrones (A Song of Ice and Fire, #1) George R.R. Martin http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1239039164s/13496.jpg 1466917], the intricate political intrigue of [b:A Clash of Kings 10572 A Clash of Kings (A Song of Ice and Fire, #2) George R.R. Martin http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1307734601s/10572.jpg 3272005], and even a little bit of the madness of [b:A Storm of Swords 62291 A Storm of Swords (A Song of Ice and Fire, #3) George R.R. Martin http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1298429990s/62291.jpg 1164465]. And, best of all, it has none of the flaws of [b:A Feast for Crows 13497 A Feast for Crows (A Song of Ice and Fire, #4) George R.R. Martin http://photo.goodreads.com/books/1288333578s/13497.jpg 1019062]. Even the ironmen are interesting in this one.