1

1:35 AM: ★☆☆☆☆Room for One More: ★★☆☆☆The New Kid: ★★★☆☆Average rating: ★★☆☆☆

This collection of stories is weaker compared to the ones that came before, but the best is saved for last.

Short thoughts on each of the stories:

1:35 AM: all about a scary alarm clock. I, too, tremble in fear whenever that thing goes off, but what I fear even more is stories without a satisfying ending. Sadly, this first story doesn't deliver well in that regard. I'm also really tired of the whole “oh, the place where I got this creepy thing has suddenly disappeared” trope that is so overused in these stories.

Room for One More: thought this was going to be a great story, very in tune with the games. But just left me wondering about the logistics of it all. I know, it's fiction, but I just kept thinking about how this would even work.

The New Kid: Thought this would be the weakest story of them all. So many of these stories go the “unlikable main character that regrets his/her actions in the last moment but still meets a grisly end” route. And sure, it's an exemplary FNaF formula story, but the ending!! Changed my opinion on this story completely and for that, I need to give it just a little bit of a higher rating than it probably deserves.