This is the second book by this author that I've been really intrigued by the premise (also [b:Hell Followed With Us 57911600 Hell Followed With Us Andrew Joseph White https://i.gr-assets.com/images/S/compressed.photo.goodreads.com/books/1630498579l/57911600.SY75.jpg 90726926]) but the execution has been...well really not for me. And part of that I think is that White is really writing for a trans audience and I hope that readers who feel represented by these books will read them and get what they need from them. But also in both cases it feels like the worldbuilding is really...cursory? Like here I just really wanted to know more about this magical apprenticeship/arranged marriage situation because in some cases it seemed like there were very clear rules about it but then also kind of like, it just existed to set up the scenario? Which I guess is kind of always the point of fiction. IDK IDK I just didn't care for this. Again other readers may find what they need here, especially ones looking for trans romance and also maybe a kind of historical Handmaid's Tale kind of vibe...idk there are definitely vibes here that will appeal to some readers. Just like, not me!!
this is an important topic and it makes a really compelling argument for why indigenous mascots are harmful. it's pretty didactic by design and I think it would be best used in a classroom setting.
also like I'm not a huge poetry expert but sometimes I read novels in verse and I'm like “yes gorgeous concise compelling” and sometimes I'm like “feels like you just used a lot of extra line breaks here” and this was more of the latter.
This had some humor to it but ultimately wasn't really my cup of tea. By nature retellings of classics are going to be sort of predictable so the job is to make the new twists interesting enough or to make the characters compelling enough that you are happy to be along for the ride even when you know the final destination. And IMO this didn't quite hit the mark. May appeal more to younger readers especially ones hungry for queer romance.
I still love this series and the concept for it, and I was relieved to get a followup on Antsy's life, but I wished I had brushed up a little bit on all the previous books before reading this one since it involves a lot of Lore from previous books. Still: a good read and a thoughtful depiction of breaking the cycle of generational violence (with bonus talking animals).