the plot is thickening
I love the angels and the witches

Iconic series. So much nostalgia.
I forgot how the writing style was in the first book and boy I am glad it improves over time.
Cringy from time to time, but then again i'm 18 and this is marketed for kids

Mal is boring. I don't like him. Don't like his jealousy. Just byeee
I love nikolai though and this book was really good and intense

“take care, seaweed brain”
“you too, wise girl”

Good book, not too strong.
Loved the POV's again.
Pacing was better than TNP, but a tad slow.
Love the introduction of rock & fallen leaves and the rich history of the lake territories

An all time favorite and an all time favorite character. Katniss is someone I relate to and the series is written so well. This reread (of the series ) was in honour of ballad of songbirds and snakes!

Not as good as the second, but better than the first. Not much to say.

Loved this one! Much better than the first one and made much more sense to me! I could actually understand the clues and lead up to the reveal in this one instead of me being confused the whole of caraval because of the clues

Good book, interesting concept and plotpoints but a weak execution. For a debut it absolutely works and she has two books to go. I was disappointed with the actual caraval and the clues - I didn't understand any of the clues or how she solved them and I think that's my biggest issue with the book

So many thoughts and all I can say is that I loved it. I wish we would have gotten more of this universe and this lore. It is so intensely good and I'm so happy

So so so good. The concept and worldbuilding is unique and amazing and just. I have no words. I am in love with all of this

Absolutely amazing book
The writing is just so good.

BEST BOOK SO FAR !!

Such a good book.
The ending absolutely destroyed me in the best way possible.

3.5 stars**

I liked this book very much, but its not my favorite. Not huge on romances personally

This ending was very good.
Also still a chefs kiss for the characters, plot and just the series.