August 13, 2024

No chemistry and the plot wasn't super engaging

April 12, 2024
June 25, 2024

I am SO impressed with this book. I really loved when u think Athelas really is going to just become Camellia's next ‘master' or whatever and then BOOM actually he's helping her FREE HERSELF 4ever. Beautiful. Also appreciate that we still got a kiss lol

October 19, 2024
December 24, 2024

This was fine. The last 25% wasn't super interesting and I skimmed, but overall it was a fun read since it starts in the 1100s and ends in the 1900s.

September 3, 2024
May 22, 2024

if sevro dies in the next book i am quitting. he is my #1 favorite character right now. this series has been absolutely amazing. i love it. the ending was terrifying

July 21, 2024

I'm a little torn on how to rate this - the book was great, I just started to lose interest in the second half. But the descriptions were so rich and good. Santángel was an interesting male lead and i loved his backstory. Luzia was a little bit boring of a female character but overall a good read.

July 26, 2024

The book and story and ending were THE BEST. this book delivered, 100%.

July 23, 2024

did not like the frog even tho I knew he was the love interest.he was kinda weird. did not pass vibe check

mostly kept reading to see the evil cousin get his due by the end.

April 21, 2025

i started this some months ago but just couldn't get into it after how much i loved the agony of the first book. maybe i'll come back to this later.

View

DNF at 25 pages in, it reads more like a wattpad from 2015 than a book I'd be interested in. I'm sure it's great if someone is in the mood for a shallow, mildly entertaining read

May 12, 2024

liked this book when i was in middle/high school but i think it's too young for me now. dnf

January 3, 2025

Dnf at 33%.... The magic system was super interesting but Gideon and Rune felt flat, and I just couldn't get into the story

July 25, 2024

Eurgh
Did not dig the way that women were written about in this book. Dnf at 15%

November 5, 2024
September 21, 2024
January 20, 2025

I am 12% in and still haven't met Niccolo. i guess he hasn't quite risen yet. It's been an extremely literary text, meaning there's a lot of detail that should be engaging but is actually just confusing. not sure if I will try again later to find niccolo.

May 7, 2025