3.5
I enjoyed Sally Rooney's writing in this novel a lot more than in her other books but the story and the characters were not for me. I found them unlikeable most of the time and all the things they talked about and how they talked about them really didn't do it for me. There were some parts that I really loved, so it's quite unfortunate..
I highly recommend checking out the trigger/content warnings for this book. Frankly, the descriptions in this book were too graphic for me, making me uncomfortable and with the disjointed narrative, it confused me a lot, as I tend to struggle with narratives that jump back and forth in time.
I enjoyed reading some parts, especially since it addresses certain things and problems of their society. I didn't find any of the characters likeable but interesting enough to read about them, so it wasn't too bad, but the writing really wasn't for me.
This book is such a good read! I am sadly not too interested in the parts about chemistry or trying to understand it but I loved how Levi connected the elements with life, making analogies.
I love the writing though, the stories about WWII are so sad and tragic at times, pulling at my heartstrings. Most of the time the chapters/stories were a bit too short for me, I always need some time to get attached and this book barely gave me the chance to do so.
There's something about the atmosphere and the mood in this book that is so unique – it's set in Tokyo after dark, when most people would be asleep and at home, but the few that are still up experience the city differently than they would during the day. This book captures that feeling in a way that is so special, as it explores the things that happen at night that we wouldn't and ever will know more about.
This book is really interesting to read and it touches on some elements we are introduced to, but it doesn't really explore them as deeply as I would have liked. Despite this, I still enjoyed the book and found it captivating, even though I didn't really understand everything that was going on and disliked some of the characters and the things they've said. The ending was far from satisfactory and unexpected, but despite this, I still enjoyed the book and the atmosphere it created.
i really liked it, the story was really nice!! I feel bad for Obsidian but I am glad Rye found those children. I loved how it explores a world in which people are no longer able to read, write or speak and the few that still can do one or the other, they are hated for it because people envy them.. it couldn't have been easy to find a way to communicate with each other still...
3.5
I loved the writing but overall, the book was really confusing to read. I didn't mind it because I could tell that there was a bigger picture to it and I'd hopefully find out at the end (and I did). The storylines of each individual character was rather straightforward although the relation to each other was a bit too confusing. I also enjoyed the way the book deals with so many different topics and themes; I am really impressed by the way it was all executed.
This book was kind of cute. A feel-good children's book with some issues. It's very British and presents India as the cause of Mary's sickness, not even mentioning how they colonised India, the way they talk about the natives there as well.. It bothered me a lot. But the story overall was very magical and optimistic and the characters were very cute.
4.75
I loved reading this book a lot. The writing was amazing and I was so blown away reading it all. My brain couldn't comprehend how such simple words can be so meaningful.
The second to last chapter was a bit less than mind-blowing, got a bit confusing because this book does not have a lot of punctuation, almost barely any punctuation, to be frank. I remember some commas and some question marks but that's pretty much it. Didn't bother me though, I really liked it.
TW/CW: rather explicit rape scene, murder, mention of child abuse, in particular sexual abuse
2 things:
1. I really liked the descriptions in the second half of the book.
2. I didn't like the protagonist at all. Which is why I couldn't love this book.
This book is great in the way it addresses this difficult situation from the pov of someone who grew up in Afghanistan. But other than that, I didn't like the protagonist's story. I have some issues with it, which made it really difficult for me to decide if I liked this book or not. To be frank, the protagonist is an asshole. And this whole book is about his 'redemption.' Did he redeem himself in the end? I can't say. But what I can say is that I have some issues with this book presenting him as someone who is not a good person in the first half of the novel, who mistreats his 'friend' because he can't help himself but see him more as a servant, although he pretends he doesn't, who is a liar and has fun at someone else's expense who is not even aware that they are secretly made fun of, and then tries to redeem him by 'saving' their son, who turns out to be his nephew. This is very oversimplified and I know this novel has more to offer than this but it bothers me that this redemption story can be summarised as: hey, you were a horrible person and witnessed your servant's rape but didn't do anything and then made sure their life is hell, but then find out they died, leaving their son orphaned in a really bad situation, so moving him to the US will redeem you? This part just really bothered me.. Did he become a better person? Did he learn from his mistakes? I can't tell.. Then also is he only taking his nephew to the US only because he's his nephew and he feels responsible and they're related? And taking his nephew to the US does not equal saving him. He's far from saved. He may no longer be in a bad situation but he has to deal with that traumatic experience. But does the protagonist help him or get him some professional help? A lot of things and ideas in this book are also very outdated. A product of its time, as they say. Does it excuse it though? I don't know. I just know that I am not comfortable with this, so for me it was not the best reading experience.