what was the point of this

4.5

WELCOME BACK HOLLY JACKSON

this was definitely better than the 1st book and there was some plot twists that got me. loving the slow burn too

IM SO SAD this was my fav series as a kid but now after rereading i was dissapointed :( took me way too long to finish it even with an audiobook and it felt like a chore to get thru at times

this took me 2 weeks to finish. it was solid but it didn't move me like it did most people. the saddest part was definitely chapter 8, hard one to read but besides that idk it was just fine, bit boring at times but I do love the two main characters

peak written by a man book vibe. the only reason I continued was to find out what was the secret AND THEY NEVER REAVEAL IT so now I'm annoyed (idc that that's the point of the book, it wasn't good enough to begin with to justify that lol)

2.5

cool formating, great audiobook but the story was just basic and very confusing (on purpose i'd imagine). i didn't guess who done it but I think it was impossible to do so despite the books tag line

not rating bc i think most of this went over my head but my god the last chapter made me so sad. i think I understand what the book is trying to say, especially after reading some reviews but I still don't know how to feel about it

this was so fucking disgusting but ig that's the point. 2 stars purely bc it was written very badly lol

this needs to be a movie

Great one for people who know nothing about the mystery or want to refresh their memory (me). There's no conspiracy theories and other crap, just a very well put together course of events and the aftermath of the tragedy.

don't feel like giving this one a rating bc of the content inside but I definitely liked it, especially the second chapter/part (?)

briar giving me a baby fever for 370 pages straight

3.5

this was a solid and quick read. u can pretty much guess the whole plot after reading the synopsis and i was expecting something more from this book idk

the yearning and its consequences

so fucking boring. I'd dnf after one chapter if it wasn't for the fact that I paid full price for this book and I refuse to waste my money

20/01/24 reread:

that last page still making me suicidal

(also the amount of ppl shocked over how this book went makes me laugh so bad bc how did a ya series go over your head that bad lmao)

it was just fine, like the previous volumes. this series is too corny for me but I'm 5 volumes deep so might as well finish