| #2 |  Hold Back the Tide
| 4 | 5 reads | |
| #3 |  The Tell-Tale Heart
| 4.2 | 347 reads | |
| #4 |  Rosemary's Baby
| 3.88 | 146 reads | |
| #5 |  Interview with the Vampire
| 3.76 | 702 reads | |
| #6 |  World War Z: An Oral History of the Zombie War
| 3.9 | 956 reads | |
| #7 |  Relic
| 3.87 | 157 reads | |
| #8 |  The Silent Companions
| 3.9 | 63 reads | |
| #9 |  The Haunting of Hill House
| 3.74 | 661 reads | |
| #10 |  We Have Always Lived in the Castle
| 3.95 | 539 reads | |
| #11 |  Best Ghost Stories of J.S. Le Fanu
| 0 | 0 reads | |
| #12 |  Sleep No More
| 3.67 | 4 reads | |
| #13 |  Wakenhyrst
| 3.88 | 25 reads | |
| #14 |  All's Well
| 3.8 | 71 reads | |
| #15 |  Revelator
| 3.9 | 32 reads | |
| #16 |  Grief Is the Thing with Feathers
| 3.72 | 104 reads | |
| #17 |  The Last House on Needless Street
| 3.89 | 294 reads | |
| #18 |  The Whisper Man
| 3.89 | 181 reads | |
| #19 |  Verity
| 3.73 | 910 reads | |
| #20 |  Nettle & Bone
| 4.11 | 476 reads | |
| #21 |  Carmilla
| 3.79 | 376 reads | |
| #22 |  Middlegame
| 4.07 | 168 reads | |
| #23 |  Ring Shout
| 4.04 | 253 reads | |
| #24 |  Gallows Hill
| 3.84 | 21 reads | |
| #25 |  Such Sharp Teeth
| 3.88 | 73 reads | |
| #26 |  Our Share of Night
| 3.86 | 83 reads | |
| #27 |  A House With Good Bones
| 3.74 | 193 reads | |
| #28 |  My Murder
| 3.71 | 50 reads | |
| #29 |  The Only One Left
| 3.93 | 392 reads | |
| #30 |  Spells for Forgetting
| 3.73 | 77 reads | |
| #31 |  The Whispering Muse
| 4.25 | 5 reads | |
| #32 |  The September House
| 3.86 | 109 reads | |
| #33 |  The One
| 4.01 | 254 reads | |
| #34 |  The Reformatory
| 4.51 | 65 reads | |
| #35 |  The Valancourt Book of Horror Stories: Volume One | 3 | 1 read | |
| #36 |  The Uninvited
| 4 | 3 reads | |
| #37 |  Bird Box
| 3.93 | 319 reads | |
| #38 |  Look Closer
| 4.08 | 59 reads | |
| #39 |  Diavola
| 3.72 | 54 reads |