I was expecting something more clever, given the accolades. A decent read though.

Well-written and -researched and an interesting, illuminating read. I would have given this five stars if it wasn't so damned long.

Harari does a wonderful job of weaving disparite things together.

The story feels very formulaic and only rates 3 stars with me but the artwork is so beautiful that it garners the book an extra star.

This annoyed me initially because it seems to be both fiction and memoir and I was all, “Pick one dammit!” But I really enjoyed it so fuck classification.

Reynolds needs to write more non-fiction. It would improve the world immeasurably.

The world-building is quite impressive but the pacing really ruined it for me. I spent the last hundred-plus pages wondering why it wasn't over already.

The prose is clunky and does not flow well. I'm going to stick to television/movie versions of Sherlock, thanks.

A four star book but I'm irritated by the presence of quasi-mythical agents. This is a personal beef and others may not be bothered by it.

Ultimately, this felt too convoluted for my tastes.

If you are going to use “them” as a singular pronoun, the character should never be referred to as “themselves”. The singular is “themself”. Arrrgh!

While I enjoyed this, it pales in comparison to its prequel. My main beef with this book is the thinness of Grey's motivations, which are integral to the plot but aren't strong enough to really support it.

I was reading this for the science and was disappointed. There is a lot of philosophizing here, chapters and chapters of it.

I would like to read more of this author because there's a lot of clever-funny going on here. But I am mystified by the decision to write this in 3rd person when the narrative screams 1st.

I was going to give this four stars but I'm bumping it up because my mum, who is sick in bed right now, was so very charmed and entertained by this book and she never likes anything.

Gritty and beautifully written. The subject matter is depressing though; I would love if Courtney wrote a fluffy romance one of these days...

After enjoying One of Us is Lying so thoroughly, I found this novel a tedious disappointment.