I understand what the author is doing and why, but it isn't really the story I was hoping for. There was more vengeance and secrets than I was wanting. It is a good book, but not really for me. If you liked the first one and the battle between the families, you will like this one.

This book was very atmospheric and I loved that. I disliked many of the characters and I think that was the way it was supposed to be, so that was successful. I didn't love the dual perspective though. I think I need to read this again before I decide what I really think.

Cites and Rowan's chapters felt very different and it made it hard for me to connect with both of them. I love the questions about mortality and what life means that this brought up. I didn't like the way religion was dealt with. I liked the different Scythes we get see throughout their training.

Isaki and Nakami are out exploring the city and he is working hard to learn photography. He is taking some good pictures, so it makes for some beautiful art work.

I loved the writing and the sense of place. There was sadness and poignancy and I liked those feelings. I'm not sold on the ending, but I don't hate it. I didn't like that friendship wasn't portrayed. I also wanted more of the in between years. So I liked it, but there were some things missing.

The setting was fabulous! The characters were eh. The world building was at times contradictory. The ‘message' was a little too on the nose for me.

This was a fun isolated setting mystery. I should have seen the twist coming, but I didn't! The relationships between these people was a nice touch, but it wasn't as impactful as I wanted it to be.

Aw! I am so excited to see how everyone is growing and dealing with their emotions and past and future. Of course there is a quest, but there is a lot of character growth as well. I am now caught up with the series and I have to wait for the next one.

Wow! I am so glad I picked this one up. It is so heavy and hopeful at the same time. Life is hard and making good decisions is hard, but having support along the way is hopeful. This book does a beautiful job encapsulating all that.