I was skeptical of mermaid camp just like Truly was, but it turned out to be a great setting. It also gave her what she needed to solve the mystery. I really enjoy Truly's voice and all of the Pumpkin Falls Private Eyes!

The beginning of this was slow and it took me awhile to care about both POVs. I almost gave up a couple times, but I really enjoyed Amina Al-Sirafi, so I kept going. I am so glad I did! By the middle, I was interested. By the end, I was enthralled! This is one of my new favorite authors.

I don't know a lot of the back story of Duck Grayson and this did a good job of telling the story without me needing to know a lot. A lot of the tension hinges on a miscommunication, so I didn't like that. The art was really well done especially the colors. Enjoyable read.

Wonderful!!

There is a sweet romance, an evil wizard, secrets, and an enchanted house! This book has a great balance of those things. It is cozy and it is exciting. It is suspenseful and happy. It was such a pleasure to read.

I knew who it was as fairly early on in the book and I knew about halfway why they did it. So there wasn't much of a mystery. However, I did enjoy watching Vera investigate and getting to know more about Shady Hollow and its citizens. It was a quick enjoyable read.

It was hard to listen to parts of this book because she was so raw and honest. I liked the way she presented her thoughts at the time and didn't add in a lot of what she thinks now. She was able to show to her mothers toxic traits as well as her love for her mother: