Two stars for two reasons.
One: The length. It was too long and I felt that it dragged in places. I was bored for a majority of it.
Two: Winter didn't do anything significant and she really didn't have to be in it. I don't know why she was in it, but oh well.
Also, I started reading a physical copy of this book but I got so bored that I turned to the audiobook which didn't really help, but it helped that I could listen to it on double-speed. The audiobook was...meh.
I guess that's three reasons.
I'm like too conflicted to rate this.* I didn't know what to expect going into it. Maybe I expected O'Malley to have another winner like he did with his others (although I've yet to read Lost at Sea). In the beginning, I found it somewhat comical, but then it just became obnoxious, although it might have been Lottie herself. The art style was good and fit the story, but I didn't understand the direction it [the story] was going. Even after reading the ending I'm still unsure. I want to give it a 2.5, since it wasn't the worst graphic novel I've read, but it doesn't quite deserve 3. And maybe it's just a flatout 2-star book.
*I don't want to erase any of this so I'm just going to give it 2