It's never bad, but it never rose beyond “decent” either. When it really goes for the whole “comedy of manners” vibe (which isn't very often) it can be fun, but otherwise I just found it well-written but completely unremarkable.

Really well-written period mystery-romance set in Victorian London. The romance elements are more prominent than the mystery, but both are excellently-written and populated with three-dimensional characters. I had fun with this one.

This was fun! Sometimes it feels like it's trying a bit too hard (and reading the issues in this volume one after the after can be tiring), but for the most part this is a fun and funny comic. It's a nice reprieve from the doom and gloom of a lot of recent comic series.

This was a nice read, very low-key and slice-of-life. It felt that the book was building to an emotional climax that never truly came–at least not like I had hoped/expected.

Still fun, but more focused on light side stories than the main plot. Cool for fans though.

An enjoyable continuation of a great series.

Such a good book and great continuation of the first. It's well-written and gripping with a sort of intensity and brutality that I think a lot of YA fantasy is missing. These characters are interesting and complex and I'm excited to read the next part of their story.

What an odd book. Like everyone, I've read “The Lottery”, and this book is a really excellent expansion of Shirley Jackson's obvious skill for dark, gothic stories. I'm glad I finally read it.

I really love the movie, and I'm enjoying going back and reading what it's based on. This volume is a good start.

I received a copy of this book through NetGalley.

I liked the mixtape format, and a lot of these “tracks” were very good. After a while though, the poems started to feel repetitive and that caused them to lose some of their impact for me.

I liked this volume just as much as the first, and I'm excited for the next one!

Sure, it can be “cutesy”, but it's also pretty funny and charming. It's a very light-hearted comic with bright, colorful art and likable characters (including LGBT folks in main roles). I dunno, I liked it!

Hmm. This was interesting and weird, but it didn't really work for me. The art is a mixed bag, the watercolor backgrounds and things are very nice, but the character designs are (in my opinion) pretty unappealing. Good premise, solid execution.

The Night Gardener felt like an extended Grimms story, and that's just about the highest compliment I could give a book like this. It has an excellent creepy atmosphere combined with quality writing and a decent amount of heart, all coming together to make a very enjoyable dark fable.