Bob de Bakker

It's written too much like a book and didn't really let the panels tell the story. Every panel had descriptions like "He dodged it," something you can also see. The art is also very inconsistent.

It's a beautiful story that tells a lot with few pages.

A bit slow at times. But still a fun story, especially halfway through the book when the story develops further and comes together at times.

It repeats many elements of the books, which makes it longer than it needed to be. But it was originally intended for a board game so that people who hadn't read the books could get a vibe from the books. So it can be forgiven, but it's still mid.