This was a lot of fun. Very unique world building and magic system, great descriptive writing, good cast of characters to root for and against. I see this being billed as the author adult fantasy debut, but it did still read very YA to me. Will read the second in the duology. 

May 6, 2024

Absolutely gorgeous to read but, IMO, somewhat light in actual content.

January 29, 2024

Very cute and fun.

November 30, 2024

Interesting idea for a Sleepy Hollow retelling but for me there were too many loose threads & unanswered questions at the end to make the story feel satisfying.

November 5, 2021

This started out a little shaky for me - I had expected a more serious drama, and it was delivering very much a straight romance. By the end the story won me over, and I ended up enjoying it quite a bit.

November 24, 2020

Definitely a fun read. A few plot holes that kept me from rating higher, but I wanted to keep turning pages to see how it all played out.

April 28, 2021

There really was a lot to enjoy here - where it fell short, for me, was that I didn't realize going in that it was a YA novel. My expectations were just for something with a bit more substance, and this felt just a tad surface level for much of the read. Definitely entertaining!

November 28, 2020
September 17, 2023
August 20, 2019
March 6, 2014

This was just ridiculously good. Impossible to believe I haven't read it yet, but now I want to call in sick to work until I've read the rest of the series. Rich, complex, stunning.

View

While this was probably my least favorite in the series, I didn't dislike it nearly as much as other readers. I am also apparently the only person in the world who doesn't hate Cersei. I am taking a break from the series for a while in anticipation of the 6th book being released....some day.

March 24, 2012

Read w/Sophia for Book Club in June, 2020.

Sophia rating - 4/5
Mom rating - 4/5

June 18, 2020
May 3, 2017
January 29, 2017
February 17, 2020

As expected in such an expansive collection, the stories were hit or miss for me. Interesting to read some of the history of short story writing in America along with each decade's stories. Fiction seems to be getting better and better if this collection is an accurate representation.

August 10, 2024
November 10, 2019
View
April 12, 2024
June 1, 2020

Entertaining for the majority of the book, although the end felt a bit detached. I was much more invested in the Arjun storyline than the Guy storyline. This did break me out of a fairly significant reading slump, so that certainly makes it a good read for me.

May 24, 2020
January 24, 2015
February 16, 2014

Suffered a bit from being read directly after a novel that blew me away, but still fun, smart, and with a great message. Libba Bray has never disappointed, and I love how she constantly imagines something new and unique. I would recommend for older teens.

July 17, 2011