| #2 |  Unspeakable Things
| 3.46 | 40 reads | |
| #3 |  The Starless Sea
| 3.94 | 467 reads | |
| #4 |  Scythe
| 4.18 | 697 reads | |
| #5 |  The Bone Jar
| 3.75 | 5 reads | |
| #6 |  Educated: A Memoir
| 4.43 | 1,098 reads | |
| #7 |  The Master Magician
| 3.49 | 96 reads | |
| #8 |  The Glass Magician
| 3.61 | 105 reads | |
| #9 |  The Paper Magician
| 3.43 | 198 reads | |
| #10 |  Déjà Dead
| 3.57 | 121 reads | |
| #11 |  Have You Seen Me?
| 3.79 | 18 reads | |
| #12 |  The Girls Weekend
| 3.4 | 14 reads | |
| #13 |  The Bear and the Nightingale
| 4 | 409 reads | |
| #14 |  The Institute
| 4.02 | 520 reads | |
| #15 |  Ninth House
| 4.03 | 826 reads | |
| #16 |  The Southern Book Club's Guide to Slaying Vampires
| 3.79 | 495 reads | |
| #17 |  Devolution: A Firsthand Account of the Rainier Sasquatch Massacre
| 3.62 | 158 reads | |
| #18 |  A Curse So Dark and Lonely
| 3.89 | 201 reads | |
| #19 |  Thunderhead
| 4.34 | 441 reads | |
| #20 |  1st to Die
| 3.65 | 126 reads | |
| #21 |  Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil
| 3.82 | 213 reads | |
| #22 |  One for the Money
| 3.78 | 250 reads | |
| #23 |  The Midnight Library
| 3.79 | 2,133 reads | |
| #24 |  Dracula
| 3.86 | 1,571 reads |